Single Family for Sale: 5091 Milentz Avenue, St Louis, MO 63109

4 beds
3 full baths
1,611 sqft
$349,500
$349,500
5091 Milentz Avenue, St Louis, MO 63109
4 beds
3 full baths
1,611 sqft
$349,500
Remove from
Favorites
Add to
Favorites
Add to
Trip Map
Hide Share or
Email
Price:
$349,500

Type Single Family
Style 1.5 Story
Beds 4
Baths 3 full baths
Total Living Area 1,611 sqft
Square Footage 1,611 sqft
Garage Spaces 2
Lot Size 0.22 acres
Year Built 1925
Taxes Paid $3,615

City St Louis
County St Louis City
School District St. Louis City
Subdivision Kingshighway Park

MLS 25075458
Status Pending
DOM 2 days
Come say happy birthday to this beautiful charmer in the sought after Princeton Heights neighborhood! This FOUR bedroom, three FULL bath home has all the old world charm with beautiful original hardwood throughout, original two panel wood doors with glass knobs, laundry chutes and gorgeous trim. The kitchen has been modernized with stainless appliances, a vented hood, center island, and a butler pantry. The main floor living room with 9 foot ceilings is large and open, with a cute reading nook surrounded by windows and a decorative fireplace. Primary suite is on upper level, but there is a bedroom/full bath on main floor. Three bedrooms and two HUGE baths total on upper level. Check out the feet on the claw foot tub! So much to love outside also as home has a covered front porch , a nice paver stone patio leading to the level yard. This is a corner lot and the yard is twice the size of the surrounding homes! Basement has a toilet rough-in already in place and the ceiling mounted movie projector can stay. ***Roof is 1 year old. Windows have been replaced with double paned vinyl, plumbing and electric have been updated. Furnace 2023. Hook ups for both gas and electric dryer. Showings begin at Open House on Sunday 11/16 1-3pm. Copy and paste to see us on For The Love of Old Houses Facebook Page! https://www.facebook.com/photo?fbid=1454122553426476&set=pcb.1454124283426303

Room Features

Basement Description Walk-Out Access, Unfinished, Full

Lot & Building Features

Appliances Ice Maker, Gas Water Heater, Electric Range, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Disposal, Refrigerator, Microwave, Dishwasher
Architecture Tudor
Construction Stucco, Brick
Cooling Attic Fan, Central Air
Heating Natural Gas, Forced Air
Interior Decor Butler Pantry, Beamed Ceilings, Historic Millwork, Shower, Tub, Granite Counters, Kitchen Island
Parking Description Detached, Garage Door Opener
Sewer Public Sewer
Tax Year 2024
Taxes Paid $3,615
Water Public
Fireplaces 1

Community and Schools

Elementary School Buder Elem.
Junior High School Long Middle Community Ed. Center
Senior High School Roosevelt High

Price History of 5091 Milentz Avenue, St Louis, MO

Date Name Price Difference
11/16/2025 Listing Price $349,500 N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.

Comparable Properties Sold Near By

Low
$272,000
$185 / sqft
Average
$349,780
$211 / sqft
High
$439,000
$251 / sqft

Address City Zip Beds Baths Price Sq. Ft. $/SQFT Sold Date
This Listing St Louis 63109 4 3.0 $349,500 1,611 $217 N/A
5068 Milentz Avenue St Louis 63109 3 3.0 $325,000 1,569 $207 01/22/2025
5215 Lisette St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $278,000 1,625 $171 03/06/2025
5328 Delor Street St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $322,500 1,602 $201 02/14/2025
5190 Goethe St Louis 63109 4 2.0 $376,900 1,720 $219 05/01/2025
5405 Rosa Avenue St Louis 63109 4 2.0 $395,000 1,780 $222 04/28/2025
6007 S Kingshighway Boulevard St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $309,000 1,470 $210 09/16/2025
5328 Walsh Street St Louis 63109 4 2.0 $420,000 1,778 $236 06/13/2025
5310 Neosho Street St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $399,900 1,786 $224 06/05/2025
5116 Goethe Avenue St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $272,000 1,474 $185 09/11/2025
5424 Gresham Avenue St Louis 63109 4 2.0 $300,000 1,764 $170 08/11/2025
5519 Walsh Street St Louis 63109 4 2.0 $405,000 1,800 $225 07/30/2025
4931 Bonita Avenue St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $323,500 1,482 $218 08/20/2025
5128 Rosa Avenue St Louis 63109 3 2.0 $335,000 1,576 $213 09/04/2025
4929 Holly Hills Avenue St Louis 63109 5 3.0 $345,900 1,698 $204 11/04/2025
5454 Lisette Avenue St Louis 63109 3 3.0 $439,000 1,748 $251 11/05/2025

Map of 5091 Milentz Avenue, St Louis, MO

Location Map Street View
Photo of The Boehmer Team
Direct: 314-740-5435
Office
950 Caledonia Dr.
O'Fallon, MO 63368
636-720-1100
Listed by Meyer Real Estate, Becky Meyer & Charlie Meyer
$
20%
1.0343347639485%
6.75%
$
$
$
Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Monthly Taxes
Monthly HOA
Monthly Home Ins.
Monthly PMI

5091 Milentz Avenue (MLS #25075458) is a 1.5 story single family home located in St Louis, MO. This single family home is 1,611 sqft and on a lot of 9,627 sqft (or 0.22 acres) with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. This property was listed on 11/14/2025 and has been priced for sale at $349,500.

The 4 bedroom single family home at 5190 Goethe in St Louis is nearby and sold for $376,900 on 05/01/2025. Another nearby 3 bedroom single family home, 5068 Milentz Avenue in St Louis sold for $325,000 on 01/22/2025.

Nearby zip codes are 63110, 63116, 63123, 63125 and 63139. This property neighbors other cities such as Affton, Other and Wilbur Park.

Maris

Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listing information courtesy of: Meyer Real Estate

Listings displaying the MARIS logo are courtesy of the participants of Mid America Regional Information Systems Internet Data Exchange